Whey Protein Isolate vs Concentrate: A Detailed Comparison
Posted by Mason Brezinscak
Estimated reading time: 8 minutes
Muscle growth effectively comes down to adequate levels of protein intake and good quality protein at that. For vegans, this can be a challenge because their protein comes from plant-based protein sources that are simply lower in protein when compared to an omnivorous diet. Take a look at the table below for a clear example:
Meat protein | ||
---|---|---|
Meat | Chicken breast (grilled without skin) | 32.0 |
Beef steak (lean grilled) | 31.0 | |
Lamb chop (lean grilled) | 29.2 | |
Pork chop (lean grilled) | 31.6 | |
Fish | Tuna (canned in brine) | 23.5 |
Mackerel (grilled) | 20.8 | |
Salmon (grilled) | 24.2 | |
Cod (grilled) | 20.8 | |
Seafood | Prawns | 22.6 |
Mussels | 16.7 | |
Crabsticks | 10.0 | |
Eggs | Chicken eggs | 12.5 |
Dairy | Whole milk | 3.3 |
Semi-skimmed milk | 3.4 | |
Skimmed milk | 3.4 | |
Cheddar cheese | 25.4 | |
Half-fat cheddar | 32.7 | |
Cottage cheese | 12.6 | |
Whole milk yogurt | 5.7 | |
Low fat yogurt (plain) | 4.8 | |
Plant Protein | ||
Pulses | Red lentils | 7.6 |
Chickpeas | 8.4 | |
Beans | Kidney beans | 6.9 |
Baked beans | 5.2 | |
Tofu (soya bean steamed) | 8.1 | |
Grains | Wheat flour (brown) | 12.6 |
Bread (brown) | 7.9 | |
Bread (white) | 7.9 | |
Rice (easy cook boiled) | 2.6 | |
Oatmeal | 11.2 | |
Pasta (fresh cooked) | 6.6 | |
Nuts | Almonds | 21.1 |
Walnuts | 14.7 | |
Hazelnuts | 14.1 |
Source: British Nutrition Foundation.
You can see how plant proteins yield significantly less protein.
With current recommendations to consume 1.7 grams - 2.6 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day for optimal muscle growth, it can be difficult for vegans.
Moreover, it's recommended that vegans eat on the larger side of this number, as plant protein isn't as rich in the muscle-building amino acid leucine; one of the three BCAAs. This is a very critical component to a vegan looking to grow muscle; without eating adequate leucine you're leaving potential muscle gains on the floor. And this is what puts you at risk of not growing muscle at the same rate on a vegan diet.
Muscle building plans for vegans: How to get enough protein and leucine from plant sources
Omnivores have it easy: they can sleep-walk and still get adequate protein and leucine levels by eating standard servings of chicken, eggs, and any other animal products during the day.
But for vegans, plant proteins are also lower in leucine and are less digestible than animal proteins.
So how is this overcome? Vegans must consume the right food and supplements high in leucine:
Food | Protein per 100 g |
---|---|
Pumpkin seeds (dried, uncooked) | 30.2 |
Lentils (red, split, uncooked) | 24.6 |
Black beans (uncooked) | 21.6 |
Almonds (raw) | 21.2 |
Tempeh | 20.3 |
Tofu (calcium set) | 17.3 |
Oats (rolled) | 16.9 |
Quinoa (uncooked) | 14.1 |
Table adapted from Rogerson, 2017.
We've catered for vegans passionately here at Bulk Nutrients, with two supplements to put an end to any protein and leucine concerns!
Here are two of our biggest weapons:
To ensure you're gaining as much muscle as possible, current leucine recommendations for everybody is approximately 40-45 mg per kilogram of body weight per day. For someone who weighs 70 kilograms, this would be 3.2 grams of leucine a day.
And here's a potential issue: scientists still haven't decided how much leucine those of us who exercise need, so that's why it's better to eat on the higher side (maybe 6 grams or more) just to be safe. Again, this is where omnivores have the upper hand.
Let's take the example of Bulk Nutrients customer Natasha, a vegan who weighs 68 kilograms:
Protein requirements: 2 grams of protein x 68 kilograms = 136 grams
Leucine requirements: 45 mg x 68 kilograms = 3 grams of leucine (double to be safe = 6 grams of leucine).
So with the use of the aforementioned supplements and foods above, Natasha can get enough protein and leucine for muscle growth. And here's the second piece of good news for vegans: there's no evidence to suggest a nutritionally balanced vegan diet hinders athletic performance.
Many studies have examined this directly, here are some of the findings:
However, pea protein is still high in leucine: 100 grams of whey protein and pea protein will give you 8.6 grams and 6.4 grams of leucine respectively, making it a terrific option for muscle-seeking vegans.
The safest way to ensure maximal growth for vegans might be to take 1 and a half servings of pea protein. We've created our own great-tasting pea protein here at Bulk Nutrients used by many vegan customers looking to maximise muscle size.
It boils down to this: vegans might want to consume 20-30% extra protein a day in line with current recommendations. They must pay special attention to getting enough leucine via food and supplements, such as pea protein, BCAAs, and vegan whey protein options just like our "Future Whey" product. If appropriate attention is paid to adequate protein and leucine requirements, then vegans should be able to grow muscle at the same rate.
Like many, Dayne was once desperate to lose weight and get into shape. But everyone he asked, everything he read, lead to the same place... nowhere.
His journey started there - researching science journals and completing a Sports Nutrition Specialist qualification so he could make weight loss easier.
With over 700 recipes and articles, the Bulk Nutrients Blog has something for everyone! Find a new workout, meet our ambassadors or take a deep dive into our products today.
We're an Australian manufacturer and supplier of high quality sports supplements.
Operating since 2008, Bulk Nutrients has become one of the premier Australian brands to supply nutritional products to top level athletes, competitors and those on a journey to a healthier lifestyle.
One thing that sets Bulk Nutrients apart is that we love to talk to our customers!
Whether you need product advice, help with the website or need a change made to your order... call us on +61 3 6266 4725.
If you prefer email you can email us day or night at info@bulknutrients.com.au
For online chat, hit the 'Chat' button in the bottom right hand corner of your screen and you'll be connected to one of our lovely customer service team.
Or if you'd like to get in touch through our online contact form, that's cool too!
Terms & ConditionsSustainability StrategyPrivacy PolicyPayment InformationSitemap
All prices are in Australian dollars (AUD) and include GST unless otherwise stated.
All content copyright © Bulk Nutrients 2008 - 2024